[Buildroot] [PATCH v2] buildroot:download: Add option to download SVN or GIT repository with version control information.

[Thomas Petazzoni]

On Mon, 20 Dec 2010 16:04:09 +0000
Quotient Remainder <quotientvremainder at gmail.com> wrote:

> Lets say that you've cloned a GIT repository for PKG_X a few weeks ago
> and done a build, now you get a new configuration (probably by changing
> "local.mk" in my understanding of your scheme) and the version string
> for PKG_X now contains a value that is not present in the local clone.
> So, you type "make" and Buildroot tries to check out the specified new
> version, which will fail since the reference is unknown.  At this stage,
> I propose that Buildroot should attempt to get an update from upstream
> (git fetch origin) and then attempt to check out the version again,
> failing if this isn't possible.  It just makes things easier when
> there's distributed development going on that an individual wouldn't
> have to manually update every repository that is used (in my current
> project I have in excess of 40 and this will probably reach 100 before
> the project is complete).
> A similar principle applies more directly for SVN repository versions,
> since version checkouts are on-line.

The idea is that if you override the source directory of a package with
<pkg>_OVERRIDE_DIR, Buildroot wouldn't look at <pkg>_VERSION anymore.
It's completely up to the developer to use <pkg>_OVERRIDE_DIR to point
to a directory that contains the correct version for the sources.

> Once possible problem I envisage with this is that the built objects in
> these overridden directories will stick around.  This may lead to
> problems.  I suppose the clean/distclean/mrproper target for these could
> be called but it's hardly the most reliable approach.  You may have a
> cleaner solution in mind.

I haven't thought too much, but there are clearly issues that needs to
be solved. For example when a given package is compiled once for the
target and once for the host.

> > What I meant here is that components that are fetched from tarballs are
> > not being handled by Sonic's approach.
> 
> Aha, I think you mean that the OVERRIDE_DIR applies regardless of where
> the package comes from.  Right?

Yes.

Thomas
-- 
Thomas Petazzoni, Free Electrons
Kernel, drivers, real-time and embedded Linux
development, consulting, training and support.
http://free-electrons.com